Choosing between a precision limit switch and an oil-tight limit switch can feel like a trade-off between accuracy and protection. For two new switches in the relays contactors industrial switches space, the Cutler-Hammer 10316 H89A and the Allen-Bradley 802T-NP take different approaches. The Cutler-Hammer is priced at $55.99 and made in the United States, while the Allen-Bradley comes in at $140.00 and is made in China. The real question is whether the $84.01 extra buys what your application needs.
Quick Verdict
If your main concern is keeping costs down while getting a new, US-made precision limit switch, the Cutler-Hammer 10316 H89A is the pick. If you're replacing an Allen-Bradley 802T-NP or need the oil-tight protection that model implies, the extra $84.01 is a worthwhile investment.
Comparison Table
| Product | Price | Origin | Model | Price Bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cutler-Hammer 10316 H89A Precision Limit Switch | USD 55.99 | United States | 10316 H89A | |
| New 802T-NP For Allen-Bradley 802T-NP Oil Tight Limit Switch | USD 140.00 | China | 802T-NP |
Where Each Product Wins
- Price and origin: The Cutler-Hammer 10316 H89A wins for price and US manufacturing, coming in at $55.99.
- Oil-tight design and model clarity: The Allen-Bradley 802T-NP wins for oil-tight protection and the unambiguous 802T-NP model number.
Product Notes
Cutler-Hammer 10316 H89A Precision Limit Switch
Priced at $55.99, this new Cutler-Hammer switch is the lower-priced way to get precision limit control. It's made in the United States and includes a family of part numbers (10316 H89A, 10316H89A, 10316-H89A, H89A, 10316), which gives you several ways to match existing inventory. The 'precision' designation points to accurate, repeatable switching for automation and machinery. Choosing it over the Allen-Bradley saves you $84.01. The main limitation is that it uses the Cutler-Hammer part numbering system, not the 802T-NP model, so if your replacement process is set up around Allen-Bradley part numbers, you'll need to translate them yourself. It's a strong option when price and US origin are your priorities.
New 802T-NP For Allen-Bradley 802T-NP Oil Tight Limit Switch
This Allen-Bradley-branded 802T-NP switch costs $140.00, which is $84.01 more than the Cutler-Hammer. The higher price buys you the oil-tight design advertised in the title, plus a clean, specific model number: 802T-NP. If your existing equipment uses Allen-Bradley parts, this switch matches that ecosystem without any cross-referencing. It's also listed as new. The catch is that it's made in China, which might be a concern if your sourcing standards require US manufacturing. The oil-tight design and model clarity could justify the premium in harsh industrial settings where oil, coolant, or dust is present. If you need that protection and part-number simplicity, this is the switch to choose.
Final Choice by Use Case
Pick the Cutler-Hammer 10316 H89A if you want a new US-made precision limit switch and want to keep spending near $56. Pick the Allen-Bradley 802T-NP if you need oil-tight protection and a straightforward 802T-NP model match, and you're comfortable paying $140. The right choice depends on whether the oil-tight design and Allen-Bradley part-number alignment are worth the $84.01 upcharge for your specific machinery.
